Staffing agency vs. in-house recruitment team: Who to hire and why

Contents:

1. Staffing agency and its services
2. The main differences between staffing agencies and in-house recruitment
3. Why hire a staffing agency: Main benefits for businesses
4. Disadvantages of staffing agency’s assistance
5. Conclusion

1. Staffing agency and its services

Both agency and in-house recruitment share commonalities like talent sourcing, HR tools, and relationship-building. However, they diverge in their responsibilities, skill sets, compensation structures, branding, and career progression. Agency recruiters operate on commissions with a wider range of roles, while in-house recruiters are salaried professionals specializing in company-specific positions.

At its core, a staffing agency is your go-to partner for finding the right people to fill your company’s job openings. But it’s not just for businesses; job seekers also benefit from them.

When you team up with a staffing agency, you’re not just streamlining your hiring process. You’re unlocking a world of advantages for your company. Many companies aren’t aware of these perks.

In a nutshell, staffing agencies bridge the gap between job seekers and companies. They free up your time and resources by handling the often time-consuming hiring tasks. But let’s do some deeper research and decide if staffing agencies are as good as they seem to be. And first, we offer to think over staffing agencies’ services.

What Staffing Agency Can Do For Business?

Based on our own experience and the approach we stand on with our clients, a good staffing agency offers various services. From FreySoft’s perspective, staffing assistance includes:

1. Long-Term Hiring

In case a client is seeking to hire a full-time employee (FTE), staffing services can include:

• RPO or Crowdsourcing options.
• The Build Operate Transfer model.

What do these solutions do? Both empower the clients to access additional talent with the most relevant skill sets. Besides, it also helps seamlessly and quickly integrate newcomers into in-house teams.

2. Temporary Placement

This service is relevant for business tasks involving hypothesis testing or the need to hire temporarily. Sometimes, you just need to hire here and now but with the potential for FTE conversion later. At FreySoft, such kind of assistance includes:

• Staff Augmentation services.
• Managed Delivery solutions.

These offerings can minimize business disruptions and cater to specific, on-demand needs.

3. Extra Recruiting Resources

You may have a lot of recruiters but poor hiring performance for many reasons. Besides, you may not have a Recruitment Department at all. In both situations, we extend:

• Extra Recruiting Resources to enhance your candidate pipeline.
• An intelligent analytical tool that evaluates top and low performers within your recruiting team.

Researchers’ Team Augmentation can be used to ensure a robust candidate funnel. A good staffing agency comprises individuals who are familiar with your company and eager to join your team. 

4. Fulfilling Your Backlog

This type of assistance is used when the client needs to hire an FTE (full-time employee), but urgent tasks cannot wait. Therefore, we help with Temporary Employee solutions prior to FTE hiring to address backlog promptly.

5. Benchmarking and Market Research Services

In cases where you require market analysis before initiating the hiring process, we deliver:

• Benchmarking Services based on location and relevant skills.
• Sample solutions that optimize candidate selection based on location and pricing.

A staffing agency operates with a broad geographical presence and extensive global experience. These things help us offer the ideal balance of cost-effectiveness, speed, and skillset alignment for various businesses.

You might be also interested in:

8 steps you need to hire top tech talents
Outstaffing Vendor and Client Responsibilities: A Comprehensive Guide To The Best Productivity
6 reasons why you need outstaffing services for your EdTech startup
Recruitment Process Outsourcing (RPO) for business: Everything you need to know

2. The main differences between staffing agencies and in-house recruitment

Basically, staffing agencies and internal recruiters are different in three things:

• Scope of responsibilities
• Qualities and skills
• Salary and bonus options

Let’s dive into the details. The scope of responsibilities of recruiters from a staffing agency involves:

• work with multiple agency clients
• hiring across domains and industries
• filling temporary positions and working for specific short-term projects
• hiring for a wider variety of roles and positions

In turn, in-house recruiter’s responsibilities typically include:

• covering the internal needs of hiring for a single company 
• loyalty to a specific company culture 
• in most cases, hiring full-time positions
• hiring for specific roles tailored to a particular company

Talking about qualities and skills, a staffing agency usually needs from a recruiter:

• initiative
• a more “aggressive” and proactive attitude to work
• perfect sales skills
• multi-tasking
• ability to work on multiple projects simultaneously

As for in-house recruiters, their skills include:

• following hiring procedures based on a company’s culture
• a strong team player behavior
• focus on hiring as well as retaining
• to be ready to deliver end-to-end solutions from hiring to onboarding and retaining

Salaries and bonuses can be also different. For instance, a staffing agency can offer:

• commission for filling positions
• extra bonus for closing projects for key partners

In-house recruiters earn a salary that is often not directly based on their performance.

3. Why hire a staffing agency: Main benefits for businesses

We know a lot of reasons why businesses can capitalize on hiring a staffing agency. Here are a bunch of the most important.

1. Expertise
They know the job market, what’s hot on it and what’s not, and can easily articulate the skills your candidates need.

2. Time-Savers
You don’t need to hire and onboard extra personnel. Staffing agencies follow structured processes where roles and responsibilities are clearly defined so that they can meet your specific requirements effectively. 

3. Large Talent Pool
Agencies have robust search channels. Depending on the region, they possess a keen understanding of the cultural alignment needed for candidates.

4. Wallet-Friendly
Hiring an agency might seem like spending extra dough because they typically charge from 50% to 100% of the hired employee’s wages. However, regarding an average internal hiring time that is nearly 3 months (nearly 1 year in some regions and niches), a staffing agency is often a money-saving move in the long run, especially for temp or seasonal hirings. 

5. Flexibility
Staffing agencies can adapt faster to changing business environments than internal recruiters. Simply put, if you no longer need assistance, you can terminate the agreement or refresh it whenever you wish. 

6. Market Insights
Sometimes, you need to know some actual insider info for a better hiring strategy. Agencies can reveal market salary rates, compensation packages, and the latest hiring trends. Armed with this knowledge, you can build offers that’ll attract those skillful specialists.

But don’t you think all these benefits sound too sweet to be true for a business? Well, you are right. The staffing agency’s services don’t fit everybody.

4. Disadvantages of staffing agency’s assistance

Keep in mind that while they promise game-changing hiring results, it’s still not a one-size-fits-all solution for every business. And here’s why.

• Cost concerns
  Depending on the agency, your budget might take a hit. Agency fees can be steep compared to internal recruitment. Especially for short-term projects.

• Time expectations
  When you’re expecting lightning-fast results with hiring a rare specialist, think again. Hiring time can be just as long, depending on the specialist, niche, and skillset.

• Lack of control
  With a third-party partnership, you might lose some control over the hiring process. Your company culture and employer brand may not shine as brightly as with your in-house team. Agencies may simply not understand your business culture as well as you do. 

• Last but not least, reputation check
  Vet social proofs, score what others say about them, whatever…Avoid a pig in a poke that could cost your time and money. 

5. Conclusion

So, what to do? To hire a staffing agency or rely on internal recruitment? Before making a decision, consider such things s budget, recruitment needs, time sensitivity, your company culture, and what kind of candidates you need to hire. What is a more cost-effective option for you? Can you afford the agency’s fees or salaries for the recruitment department is more affordable for you so far? Do your in-house recruiters have enough expertise to fill positions you need right now or do they need some extra help? Besides, if you have urgent hiring needs, a staffing agency may be able to fill positions more quickly. However, in case your company places a strong emphasis on cultural fit, internal recruiters may work with the employer brand better. 

Ultimately, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer, and the decision may vary from one hiring situation to another. At FreySoft, we stand on a position that both staffing agency and in-house recruiting assist you in filling open positions with skillful candidates in record times. Many organizations use a combination of internal and external recruitment methods to meet their staffing needs effectively.